Skip to content
mob4yo

Scoring methodology

How every score is computed: the rules, the weights, and what they do not measure.

Last updated:

On this page

mob4yo scores are computed from specifications by fixed rules, with no opinion involved. The tables below are taken directly from the rules the site runs on (version v2.0), so what you see here is what is actually calculated.

What these scores do not measure

A score reflects the specification sheet alone. It does not measure real image quality, how long the battery lasts in your day, comfort in the hand, or after-sales support. Two phones with identical specifications get the same score even if they behave differently. Use it to narrow your options rather than to make the decision. It is not a test result.

How to read the tables

Each factor has a scale from 1 to 10. "60 → 4, 90 → 6.5" means a value of 60 scores 4, a value of 90 scores 6.5, and values in between are proportional. Anything below the lowest point or above the highest takes that point's score. For thickness and weight, a lower value scores higher.

Design

FactorWeightHow it scores
Thickness 30% 6 → 10, 7.5 → 9, 8.5 → 7, 10 → 5, 12 → 3
Weight 25% 150 → 10, 180 → 8.5, 200 → 7, 230 → 5, 260 → 3
Build materials 25% by stated class, from 4.5 to 10. An unrecognised value: 6
Water resistance 20% present: 9, absent: 4

Display

FactorWeightHow it scores
Refresh rate 30% 60 → 4, 90 → 6.5, 120 → 8.5, 144 → 9.5, 165 → 10
Peak brightness 30% 500 → 4, 1000 → 6, 1500 → 8, 2500 → 9.5, 4000 → 10
Panel technology 25% by stated class, from 4 to 10. An unrecognised value: 5
Screen size 15% 5 → 5, 6.1 → 7.5, 6.7 → 9, 7.2 → 8

Performance

FactorWeightHow it scores
Chipset class 60% by stated class, from 3.5 to 10. An unrecognised value: 5.5
RAM 25% 3 → 3, 6 → 6, 8 → 7.5, 12 → 9, 16 → 10
Storage 15% 64 → 3, 128 → 6, 256 → 8, 512 → 9.5, 1024 → 10

Camera

FactorWeightHow it scores
Main sensor 35% 8 → 3, 48 → 7, 50 → 7.5, 108 → 8.5, 200 → 9.5
Optical stabilization 30% present: 9, absent: 4
Video capability 20% by stated class, from 5 to 10. An unrecognised value: 4
Selfie camera 15% 5 → 3, 12 → 6.5, 20 → 8, 32 → 9, 50 → 9.5

Battery

FactorWeightHow it scores
Capacity 50% 3000 → 3.5, 4500 → 6.5, 5000 → 8, 6000 → 9.5, 7000 → 10
Wired charging speed 35% 10 → 2.5, 33 → 6, 67 → 8, 120 → 9.5, 200 → 10
Wireless charging 15% 0 → 3, 15 → 7, 50 → 9.5

Software

FactorWeightHow it scores
OS version 70% by stated class, from 3 to 9.5. An unrecognised value: 5.5
NFC support 30% present: 9, absent: 5

Value for money

Value compares the average of the other axes with what is typically expected at that price: score = 6.5 + (quality − expected) × 1.8, kept between 1 and 10. Expected quality by price in USD: $100 → 4, $200 → 5.2, $350 → 6.3, $550 → 7.3, $800 → 8.2, $1200 → 9, $2000 → 9.5. Value is not computed without a known price. So a $200 phone scoring 6.5 is excellent value, and a $1,200 phone scoring the same is poor value.

The overall score

A weighted average of the axes available, using these weights:

AxisWeight
Design10%
Display17%
Performance20%
Camera20%
Battery18%
Software8%
Value7%

When there is not enough data

We prefer "not rated" to a number with nothing behind it. An axis only gets a score when the data covers at least 40% of its factors' weight. An overall score is only published when the available axes cover at least 60% of the total weight. The factors and values behind every score are stored with it.

When scores change

Scores are recomputed when specifications, prices or the rules change. When the rules change, the version number above changes and the whole catalogue is recalculated.

Scoring methodology | mob4yo