Editorial policy
How content is prepared, reviewed and corrected, and how we stay independent.
Last updated:
On this page
Human review before publication
A human editor reads every analysis section and every article before it is published, beside the specification sheet and a fact-check report, and can edit or reject it. No text goes from preparation to the site without a person's approval, and we record who approved it and when.
Source of truth
Analysis and articles are prepared from the device's stored specification sheet and, for news, from published reports. Before text reaches the editor, every numeric claim in it is checked, in Arabic and English: capacity, wattage, refresh rate, resolution, brightness, size, memory, weight, hours, percentages, prices and benchmark results. Anything the data does not support is flagged to the editor.
Analysis and reviews
This site does not have a lab. What we publish about most devices is analysis of specifications and published information, and we call it analysis. We do not write "we tested" or "we noticed" or anything implying experience, and we do not present other people's measurements as our own. Our systems refuse to publish such statements at all, even with an editor's approval, unless it is on record that a person really used the device.
When our editor does use a device we record that, the page is then called a review, and its first-hand statements go no further than the editor's own notes.
Rule-based content
Short summaries and some frequently asked questions are composed directly from the specification sheet by fixed rules, so they state no figure the table beside them does not. Scores are computed by the declared rules in our scoring methodology; nobody writes them, or adjusts them for a particular device.
News
We follow what technology sites publish through RSS feeds, but we do not republish their text. We write our own, name and clearly link whoever published the report, and say a claim is unconfirmed when it is. When several sources cover one story we write one article and cite them all. We only summarize what reviewers say when we have several independent reviews, and we attribute each statement to whoever made it.
Independence
We do not accept payment for a score, a favourable opinion or a position in a list. The scoring rules do not know who advertises with us, and advertisers do not see text before it is published. Our advertising policy sets out what we earn and from where.
Corrections
When a specification error is found we fix how the value is extracted and recompute what it affected, so every device with the same pattern is corrected rather than only the page that was reported. When a text is wrong we correct it and update the page's date. To report an error: our contact page.